Background information

Are we commercialising pets too much? This is what the animal ethicist says

Darina Schweizer
15.12.2023
Translation: machine translated

Bows, jumpers and other accessories: many pet owners dig deep into their wallets for their pets. Animal ethicist Nico Müller explains when commercialisation and humanisation become critical. Or are we even dehumanising our animals?

If you look around in our online shop or in pet shops, you will be almost overwhelmed by products for four-legged friends. There is now an animal counterpart for almost everything you can buy as a human. Is this morally justifiable? I asked the animal ethicist Nico Müller from the University of Basel.

Which pet products do you consider critical?
I would strongly advise against plastic hamster balls or balls in which the animals can roll around the home. These are unhygienic and harbour a high risk of injury. Anyone using them may even be in breach of Article 4, Paragraph 2 of the Swiss Animal Welfare Act. But I also don't think much of accessories and costumes if they have no function for the animal.

Are we humanising our animals with these products?In the case of accessories and costumes, yes, to some extent. For example, some people attribute fashion tastes to their animals that they don't actually have. In doing so, they project their own needs and desires onto the animal. As a result, the animal itself fades into the background.

When is dehumanisation the case?
For example, when owners are of the opinion: As long as my pet is still eating, it's fine. I only need to go to the vet when it's obviously suffering. In doing so, they simplify the animal and make it less human-like than it really is. That's probably why around 93 per cent of Swiss dogs don't have health insurance.

Would that be necessary?
Absolutely. When an animal falls ill, the cost of treatment can quickly mount up. Without insurance, it is a matter of luck whether an animal is treated - or whether it is euthanised because it is cheaper. Generally speaking, depending on what is more convenient for people, they attribute or deny human characteristics to animals.

Do we need animals at all?
We have been living with dogs for around 14,000 years and with cats for around 6,000. Direct contact with animals is a legitimate need. But that doesn't justify torture breeding. If you look at the full animal shelters, you should ask yourself whether pets should still be bred.

In which direction do you think the relationship with our animals will develop in the future?
The fact that even the Federal Council has now recognised that meat consumption needs to be reduced makes me hopeful that our relationship with animals will become less self-evident. What this could mean for pets is difficult to say. I would like to see us trivialise them less and treat them more maturely.

What would that mean in concrete terms?
For example, that we take out pet health insurance and that this even becomes public and compulsory in future. I would also think it would make sense to reintroduce compulsory dog training courses throughout Switzerland.

Why?
Not only to reduce the number of bites, but above all to educate people about how to handle animals. At the moment, it is left to chance where owners find information. This can also lead to the development of cruel practices, such as pushing the snouts of dogs that are not house-trained into faeces. Basically, I would like us to take the needs of our pets as seriously as our own.

By the way: Our Category Management has been informed about the criticised cattle prods, cattle suction cups and hamster balls. Some have already been removed from the range.

Do you think we commercialise and humanise our animals too much? Tell me in a comment.

Cover photo: Shutterstock/BearFotos

19 people like this article


User Avatar
User Avatar

I love anything with four legs or roots - especially my shelter cats Jasper and Joy and my collection of succulents. My favourite things to do are stalking around with police dogs and cat coiffeurs on reportages or letting sensitive stories flourish in garden brockis and Japanese gardens. 


Health
Follow topics and stay updated on your areas of interest

Pets
Follow topics and stay updated on your areas of interest

Background information

Interesting facts about products, behind-the-scenes looks at manufacturers and deep-dives on interesting people.

Show all

These articles might also interest you

  • Background information

    Adopting a cat, part 3: those turbulent first 24 hours

    by Darina Schweizer

  • Background information

    First world problems: when children don’t know what to wish for

    by Michael Restin

  • Background information

    Supernanny for cats – how this animal psychologist teaches manners

    by Darina Schweizer