Kim Muntinga
Review

"Football Manager 27": Finally good again?

Kim Muntinga
9.11.2026
Translation: machine translated
Pictures: Kim Muntinga

After the disappointing predecessor, I gave 'Football Manager 27' another chance. The revised user interface and more pleasant controls bring the fun back. However, some weaknesses remain.

My first season with Grasshoppers Zürich could hardly have gone better. I won the Swiss championship with 88 points, and in the cup final, I defeated our city rivals, FC Zürich, 3-1. The double is perfect. In the following season, I qualified for the Champions League league phase in the playoffs, providing my club with financial breathing room.

I have now spent around 35 hours with «Football Manager 27» and have reached February 2028. During this time, I haven't just racked up plenty of goals and victories, but also gained a good impression of what Sports Interactive has changed compared to its predecessor. And where the developers still need to make improvements.

Out of the menu jungle

The user interface was my biggest point of criticism regarding the predecessor. Nested menus, cumbersome navigation, and endless scrolling made even simple tasks unnecessarily complicated. Instead of taking care of my team, I was constantly searching for information. Sports Interactive has noticeably improved this.

The difference is noticeable even in everyday tasks. I can switch between the squad overview, player profiles, and the tactics screen much faster. Lineups and substitutions are also easier to handle. Training management has become clearer. I now complete many tasks with fewer clicks.

Formation on the left, squad on the right: Here I put together my team for the next match.
Formation on the left, squad on the right: Here I put together my team for the next match.

The operation is still not perfect, however. Some information remains hidden behind unnecessary clicks. I am particularly unimpressed by the preset views. Often, details I need for my decisions are missing. While I can customize the overviews, it costs time and doesn't always work as comfortably as I would like.

Compared to «FM26», this is a clear step forward. I just can't warm up to the dark gray user interface and its purple tint visually. For my taste, it is still hideous. Fortunately, there are community skins available again that I can use to customize the design. I've already picked out a few, though I haven't tried them out yet.

A new starting goalkeeper and old problems

One of my first tasks at Grasshoppers is squad planning. I get an overview of the team, check for potential reinforcements, and consider which players I want to plan with long-term. In goal, things seem clear at first: Justin Hammel is intended to be the starting keeper, and Marvin Hübel is to be his backup.

But then Hammel throws a wrench in my plans. The Swiss player doesn't want to extend his expiring contract. So, I sell him to SV Elversberg for 925,000 euros and promote Hübel to the new number one. The then 23-year-old seizes his chance and develops into a reliable backbone. He remains between the posts in the second season as well. Furthermore, I am able to extend his contract relatively cheaply until 2032.

An unplanned personnel decision has become a long-term solution. Marvin Hübel has seized his chance.
An unplanned personnel decision has become a long-term solution. Marvin Hübel has seized his chance.

Such stories are a huge part of the fascination of «Football Manager» for me. I enjoy discovering young talents, nurturing them, and being happy when they become key players. Even after a change of club, I keep an eye on their further careers. Squad planning is therefore one of my favorite activities.

Little has changed in terms of transfers and contract negotiations. The processes work largely as they did in the predecessors. However, I still miss one practical feature: I used to be able to exclude certain clauses from further negotiations. For example, if a club wants to receive 25 percent of the revenue from a future resale, I can reject this demand, but I cannot prevent the club from bringing it up again in the next offer.

Staff management could also be more comfortable. While player abilities are represented with concrete numerical values, coaches and scouts still only have gradations like «Good» or «Outstanding». To this day, I wonder who at Sports Interactive came up with this stupid idea.

For players, Football Manager provides me with concrete attribute values. For my staff's abilities, however, I now have to estimate based on general terms. I preferred it the old way.
For players, Football Manager provides me with concrete attribute values. For my staff's abilities, however, I now have to estimate based on general terms. I preferred it the old way.

I also wish for more control over youth development. In older versions, I could determine whether my U19 and U21 teams would adopt the tactics of the pros or play according to their coaches' ideas. I haven't found a corresponding setting in «FM27» yet. This would allow me to prepare young talents more specifically for the tactical requirements of the first team.

Besides that, I miss clear statistics for my youth teams. While I can view appearances, goals, and assists for the U21s, this information is missing in the U19 squad overview. Apparently, they are hidden in the individual player profiles under «Other matches». Why Sports Interactive doesn't display this information directly in the overview or offer it as a selection is beyond me.

More freedom on the tactics board

There were times when I spent hours tinkering with unusual tactics in «Football Manager». Once, I even experimented with a 2-3-2-3 system without a real striker. Instead, three attacking midfielders were supposed to provide the necessary goal threat. And indeed: the unusual system worked surprisingly well.

I love experimenting with formations and player roles and trying out new approaches. In my current career with Grasshoppers, however, I haven't really had the chance to do that yet. So far, I am consciously sticking largely to my proven tactics. Although: for the second season, I have made a few changes. As the reigning champion, I am no longer an underdog, and my young squad has improved significantly.

I particularly like that I can set up my team differently with and without the ball. This feature, already introduced with «FM26», allows me to define separate formations and player roles for both phases of play.

My recipe for success in the first season: high pressing, quick transition play, and a compact defense.
My recipe for success in the first season: high pressing, quick transition play, and a compact defense.

With my Grasshoppers, I generally rely on a 4-2-3-1 with high pressing and quick transition play. In the first season, two central midfielders operated behind a number ten when in possession. Without the ball, both dropped back to the defensive midfield positions, while the striker dropped back next to the attacking midfielder.

For the second season, I changed the basic approach from «Balanced» to «Attacking» and changed my midfield. When in possession, two midfielders now play slightly deeper. Against the ball, a defensive midfielder secures the space behind two central midfielders. In addition, there are other minor adjustments to player roles and team instructions.

The different setups give me more freedom to implement my idea of the game. However, I still need to test how much tactical depth is actually involved in more detail.

New are the so-called «Tactical Tweaks». With these, I can change individual tactical instructions directly during a match without having to open the tactics menu first. For example, I can have my wingers swap sides, increase the tempo, or reduce the pressing. Furthermore, I can give specific instructions to individual players, such as putting more pressure on an opponent.

Besides the game tempo, I can, for example, change the pressing or the orientation of my wingers directly during a match.
Besides the game tempo, I can, for example, change the pressing or the orientation of my wingers directly during a match.

On the pitch, «FM27» also makes progress. Players move more naturally, and running paths and combinations seem more convincing. Occasionally, however, strange goalkeeper actions or incomprehensible defensive behavior cause me to shake my head.

In such attacking situations, I pay particular attention to how my players use open spaces and support each other.
In such attacking situations, I pay particular attention to how my players use open spaces and support each other.

The football world could be more alive

Outside of my own club, the football world still seems pale. Of course, managers change employers, clubs sign new players, and championships are decided elsewhere. However, I only notice much of this on the sidelines. The corresponding news gets lost among the numerous reports of my daily managerial life. Yet, I would like to follow, for example, what becomes of former staff members and how their careers develop. Here, Sports Interactive has been leaving a lot of potential on the table for years.

Such reports are a good start. I would find it even more exciting if the game followed the developments of individual managers and players more closely.
Such reports are a good start. I would find it even more exciting if the game followed the developments of individual managers and players more closely.

Conversations with players, the media, and the board have also changed little. Press conferences still consist of the same questions that I have already answered countless times in past «Football Manager» games. That's why I usually leave them to my staff. Players occasionally react in ways that are hard to understand. One complains about a lack of playing time, even though they are on the pitch regularly. Another demands more salary, even though their contract still has several years to run. Such contradictions have unfortunately accompanied the series for years.

What I also miss are the small details that give a long career more personality. A detailed season review, for example, that summarizes the most important successes, players, and special moments once again. Such features don't change anything about the actual gameplay, but they ensure that one season doesn't just feel like the next.

My club's season review shows me the most important results and players. For a review of an entire football year, that's not enough for me.
My club's season review shows me the most important results and players. For a review of an entire football year, that's not enough for me.

Technically, «FM27» makes a good impression. In my playtime so far, I haven't had any crashes. Even with a database of around 100,000 players and several active leagues, the calculation between matchdays runs pleasantly fast.

However, there are two annoying display errors in the news. When scrolling through, the view occasionally jumps to the top, even though I haven't read all the news further down yet. In addition, I receive incomplete feedback on players I have offered via the Transfer Room. For example, the game informs me that no interested parties were found for three players, but only names one. Which two other players are affected remains open.

Especially with extensive squad planning, such incomplete feedback creates unnecessary work.
Especially with extensive squad planning, such incomplete feedback creates unnecessary work.

«Football Manager 27» was provided to me by SEGA / Sports Interactive. The game will be released on November 10th for PC, Mac, PlayStation 5, and Xbox Series.

In a nutshell

Looking forward to the next season again

"Football Manager 27" gets a lot right again that its predecessor got wrong. The significantly improved controls mean I can finally focus on what I enjoy so much about the series: building a club for the long term, developing talent, and shaping my team according to my vision. However, returning to old strengths is not enough for me. Many weaknesses that plagued earlier installments are still present. The football world could be more vibrant, interactions more credible, and some administrative functions more convenient. Furthermore, I miss some practical features from older versions. For those who already struggled with "FM26", I would recommend making the switch. On the other hand, those who are satisfied with "FM24" should carefully weigh whether the new tactical options and the revised match engine justify a change. Nevertheless, I am once again eager to accompany my Grasshoppers through many more seasons. And after last year's disappointment, that is perhaps the greatest compliment I can pay "FM27".

Pro

  • significantly improved operation and navigation
  • exciting squad planning and development of own talents
  • diverse opportunities for tactical tinkering
  • improved match engine with more natural movements

Contra

  • partly impractical views and operating errors
  • missing and hard-to-find features
  • a not very lively football world
  • repetitive and partly illogical interactions
  • cumbersome employee and junior staff management
Header image: Kim Muntinga

10 people like this article


User Avatar
User Avatar

My interests are varied, I just like to enjoy life. Always on the lookout for news about darts, gaming, films and series.


Gaming
Follow topics and stay updated on your areas of interest

Review

Which films, shows, books, games or board games are genuinely great? Recommendations from our personal experience.

Show all

These articles might also interest you

Show all

These articles might also interest you

9 comments

Avatar
later