Product test

Bloody pants! Washout or winner? My first time using period underwear

12.5.2022

Period underwear stopped looking like granny pants a long time ago. You can now get the reusable alternative to disposable pads and tampons in a wide variety of designs. But I haven’t ever tried them – that is, until now. Pants on, let’s go.

It’s day four of my cycle. The worst of the bleeding (and cramps – yay) of my period is over and I’ve finally plucked up the courage to slip into my very first period pants. It slowly dawns on me why the slogan «Dare To Care» is printed on the packaging of my Selenacare period underwear. It actually does take a lot of effort not to reach for the tampons and single-use pads in the bathroom cabinet. What if they leak through to my clothes and end up being bloody pants in the very literal sense? But, thanks to my home office set-up, there’s hardly been a better time to put the knickers to the test. So I risk it and pull on the underwear with its built-in period protection. It stays in place and is comfortable. Really comfortable.

It sparks a sense of hope. Once I’d ruled out the menstrual cup for personal reasons, I was stuck with tampons and disposable pads again. But I wanted an option that was more practical and as environmentally friendly as possible. These washable pants could be the alternative I was looking for. Or at least, something to add to my period toolkit. Putting them to the test will let me know for sure.

Selenacare has four different types of pants to choose from: Active, Hipster, Brasiliana and Classic. I opted for the latter:

Period underwear

Selenacare Classic

This version comes with a lacy waistband and looks most like my normal underwear. The pants also hold 25 ml of blood securely. In other words, just enough absorbency for the start and end of my period. Or as Selencare puts it: «perfect for the light and medium days». The briefs are made of 59% nylon, 20% cotton, 10% polyester, 7% elastane and 4% polyurethane. According to the manufacturer, you can wash them at 30° to 60° in the machine and reuse them up to 60 times. The absorbent part on the gusset is four-layered and has in-built antibacterial protection, meaning it’s slightly thicker than the rest. But it’s not comparable to regular pads, which are too rigid and inflexible. Comfort? Check. But is it still comfortable to wear when you add blood to the equation.

You need four layers of fabric to prevent leaks.

Let it flow

If I can overcome my reservations about period underwear once, I can do it again. I’ve since worn the pants a number of times during my period and made up my mind about them.

At first, I’d hoped to be able to wear the underwear to bed, and then I wouldn’t need to have a tampon in my body all night. In theory, it’s a great idea. The only issue is feeling the synthetic fabric on my lady bits. It made me sweat a lot at night, despite the fact it’s supposed to be breathable. What resulted was a restless sleep. However, I find the knickers a real godsend during the day, especially when I’m working from home. There’s no more annoyance of having to change tampons and stuff like that, no damp feeling, no leaks, no unpleasant smell.

In theory, I can wear the pants all day – at least that’s what the manufacturer says. Provided my period isn’t too heavy. The underwear can’t absorb more than 25 ml of blood. But the thing is, the black material makes it difficult to gauge how much blood is already there. Which is why I tend to go more with my gut. As soon as the pants start to feel the slightest bit wet, I’ll change them. For me, that’s every four to five hours on light days. Meanwhile, on heavier days, the pants work in tandem with my tampon. Almost as a security measure. At least that means I avoid using a pad (and the awful sticky strips) that I’d normally have reached for. Unfortunately, this brand doesn’t yet have a version that offers greater absorbency.

Selenacare recommends that customers size up.

While the pants are straightforward to use, they do require more effort when it comes to looking after them. For instance, I have to wash them by hand in cold water after wearing them before they can go in the machine. Putting them in the tumble dryer is an absolute no-no, as the drying process can shorten the life of the pants. Then there’s the issue of what comes off in the water. Although synthetic period pants mean I get to reduce the amount I throw away, I end up producing microplastics when I put them in the washing machine.

Another downside is that, compared to a menstrual cup, one pair of period pants alone isn’t enough. Which is why I’m thinking of getting more. Perhaps also some from other brands. That way I can test out other alternatives.

Verdict

All in all, I’m pleasantly surprised. The Selenacare version looks pretty and is comfortable to wear – during the day, at least. Until I find pants that can handle my heavier flow days along with the light, I’ll keep using these knickers for the start and end of my period. And in between, they’ll save me using a pad or two.

59 people like this article

Natalie Hemengül

Senior Editor

Natalie.Hemenguel@digitecgalaxus.ch

As a massive Disney fan, I see the world through rose-tinted glasses. I worship series from the 90s and consider mermaids a religion. When I’m not dancing in glitter rain, I’m either hanging out at pyjama parties or sitting at my make-up table. P.S. I love you, bacon, garlic and onions.

Sustainability

Follow topics and stay updated on your areas of interest

Health

Follow topics and stay updated on your areas of interest

Product test

Our experts test products and their applications. Independently and neutrally.

Show all

These articles might also interest you

Product test
Protection against the wind: Mammut’s Aenergy running vest is impressive
by Martin Jungfer
Product test
With a collar, but still cool: Dagsmejan's new classic pyjamas tested
by Martin Jungfer
Product test
Menstrual cups: yay or nay?
by Natalie Hemengül

9 comments

later

Search

Bloody pants! Washout or winner? My first time using period underwear

Let it flow

Verdict

These articles might also interest you

Protection against the wind: Mammut’s Aenergy running vest is impressive

With a collar, but still cool: Dagsmejan's new classic pyjamas tested

Menstrual cups: yay or nay?

9 comments

9 comments

Galaxus Deal of the day